ISO 42001 is the upcoming standard for AI Management Systems (AIMS), similar in structure to ISO 27001 for information security. While the full standard is not yet widely published, the main requirements for an internal audit of an ISO 42001 AIMS can be outlined based on common audit principles and the expected clauses in the standard. Here’s a structured view:
1. Audit Scope and Objectives
- Define what parts of the AI management system will be audited (processes, teams, AI models, AI governance, data handling, etc.).
- Ensure the audit covers all ISO 42001 clauses relevant to your organization.
- Determine audit objectives, e.g.,:
- Compliance with ISO 42001.
- Effectiveness of risk management for AI.
- Alignment with organizational AI strategy and policies.
2. Compliance with AIMS Requirements
- Check whether the organization’s AI management system meets ISO 42001 requirements, which likely include:
- AI governance framework.
- Risk management for AI (AI lifecycle, bias, safety, privacy).
- Policies and procedures for AI development, deployment, and monitoring.
- Data management and ethical AI principles.
- Roles, responsibilities, and competency requirements for AI personnel.
3. Documentation and Records
- Verify that documentation exists and is maintained, e.g.:
- AI policies, procedures, and guidelines.
- Risk assessments, impact assessments, and mitigation plans.
- Training records and personnel competency evaluations.
- Records of AI incidents, anomalies, or failures.
- Audit logs of AI models and data handling activities.
4. Risk Management and Controls
- Review whether risks related to AI (bias, safety, security, privacy) are identified, assessed, and mitigated.
- Check implementation of controls:
- Data quality and integrity controls.
- Model validation and testing.
- Human oversight and accountability mechanisms.
- Compliance with relevant regulations and ethical standards.
5. Performance Monitoring and Improvement
- Evaluate monitoring and measurement processes:
- Metrics for AI model performance and compliance.
- Monitoring of ethical and legal adherence.
- Feedback loops for continuous improvement.
- Assess whether corrective actions and improvements are identified and implemented.
6. Internal Audit Process Requirements
- Audits should be planned, objective, and systematic.
- Auditors must be independent of the area being audited.
- Audit reports must include:
- Findings (compliance, nonconformities, opportunities for improvement).
- Recommendations.
- Follow-up to verify closure of nonconformities.
7. Management Review Alignment
- Internal audit results should feed into management reviews for:
- AI risk mitigation effectiveness.
- Resource allocation.
- Policy updates and strategic AI decisions.
Key takeaway: An ISO 42001 internal audit is not just about checking boxes—it’s about verifying that AI systems are governed, ethical, and risk-managed throughout their lifecycle, with evidence, controls, and continuous improvement in place.
An Internal Audit agreement aligned with ISO 42001 should include the following key components, each described below to ensure clarity and operational relevance:
🧭 Scope of Services
The agreement should clearly define the consultant’s role in leading and advising the internal audit team. This includes directing the audit process, training team members on ISO 42001 methodologies, and overseeing all phases—from planning to reporting. It should also specify advisory responsibilities such as interpreting ISO 42001 requirements, identifying compliance gaps, and validating governance frameworks. The scope must emphasize the consultant’s authority to review and approve all audit work to ensure alignment with professional standards.
📄 Deliverables
A detailed list of expected outputs should be included, such as a comprehensive audit report with an executive summary, gap analysis, and risk assessment. The agreement should also cover a remediation plan with prioritized actions, implementation guidance, and success metrics. Supporting materials like policy templates, training recommendations, and compliance monitoring frameworks should be outlined. Finally, it should ensure the development of a capable internal audit team and documentation of audit procedures for future use.
⏳ Timeline
The agreement must specify key milestones, including project start and completion dates, training deadlines, audit phase completion, and approval checkpoints for draft and final reports. This timeline ensures accountability and helps coordinate internal resources effectively.
💰 Compensation
This section should detail the total project fee, payment terms, and a milestone-based payment schedule. It should also clarify reimbursable expenses (e.g., travel) and note that internal team costs and facilities are the client’s responsibility. Transparency in financial terms helps prevent disputes and ensures mutual understanding.
👥 Client Responsibilities
The client’s obligations should be clearly stated, including assigning qualified internal audit team members, ensuring their availability, designating a project coordinator, and providing access to necessary personnel, systems, and facilities. The agreement should also require timely feedback on deliverables and commitment from the internal team to complete audit tasks under the consultant’s guidance.
🎓 Consultant Responsibilities
The consultant’s duties should include providing expert leadership, training the internal team, reviewing and approving all work products, maintaining quality standards, and being available for ongoing consultation. This ensures the consultant remains accountable for the integrity and effectiveness of the audit process.
🔐 Confidentiality
A robust confidentiality clause should protect proprietary information shared during the engagement. It should specify the duration of confidentiality obligations post-engagement and ensure that internal audit team members are bound by equivalent terms. This builds trust and safeguards sensitive data.
💡 Intellectual Property
The agreement should clarify ownership of work products, stating that outputs created by the internal team under the consultant’s guidance belong to the client. It should also allow the consultant to retain general methodologies and templates for future use, while jointly owning training materials and audit frameworks.
⚖️ Limitation of Liability
This clause should cap the consultant’s liability to the total fee paid and exclude consequential or punitive damages. It should reinforce that ISO 42001 compliance is ultimately the client’s responsibility, with the consultant providing guidance and oversight—not execution.
🛑 Termination
The agreement should include provisions for termination with advance notice, payment for completed work, delivery of all completed outputs, and survival of confidentiality obligations. It should also ensure that any training and knowledge transfer remains with the client post-termination.
📜 General Terms
Standard legal provisions should be included, such as independent contractor status, governing law, severability, and a clause stating that the agreement represents the entire understanding between parties. These terms provide legal clarity and protect both sides.
Internal Auditing in Plain English: A Simple Guide to Super Effective ISO Audits
Responsible AI in the Age of Generative Models: Governance, Ethics and Risk Management
AI Governance: Applying AI Policy and Ethics through Principles and Assessments
AIMS and Data Governance – Managing data responsibly isn’t just good practice—it’s a legal and ethical imperative.
DISC InfoSec previous posts on AI category
InfoSec services | InfoSec books | Follow our blog | DISC llc is listed on The vCISO Directory | ISO 27k Chat bot | Comprehensive vCISO Services | ISMS Services | Security Risk Assessment Services | Mergers and Acquisition Security
